really this is more like 2.5. this is nothing in comparison to the rest of the series. I found it more like porn with plot and the was weak.My main problems:1. How in the hell did it take them so long to know who the ghost is. Are they all idiots? 2. I am not sure that the Sound play was sanitary. Dean kept that thing in there for days! That does not seem comfortable or healthy. Although to be fair, I have no experience in this. I just started skimming the sex scenes as I got bored. The next book is just so much better than this one!